Below is a link to the Palm Beach County Circuit Court decision by Judge Colbath granting a new trial in the Goodman case. This was based on juror Dennis DeMartin concealing during jury selection that his ex-wife had a DUI conviction.
Goodman Order Granting New Trial – PDF
Based on our read, it seems like Judge Colbath had a difficult decision to make, and he made the correct one. Here are some snippets of the decision.