Below is a link to the Palm Beach County Circuit Court decision by Judge Colbath granting a new trial in the Goodman case. This was based on juror Dennis DeMartin concealing during jury selection that his ex-wife had a DUI conviction.
Goodman Order Granting New Trial – PDF
Based on our read, it seems like Judge Colbath had a difficult decision to make, and he made the correct one. Here are some snippets of the decision.
In the next two we see that DeMartin did have issues with his ex-wife’s DUI arrest and that he did not disclose it.